First off, it's good to see another true car enthusiast here on PW. I really enjoy discussing cars with people that know what they're talking about.
Your point about driving dynamics only being part of the entire experience when driving exotic/luxury cars is valid. Eventhough I focus mainly on the dynamics of the car I still talk about other things that are worth mentioning. With the Supersports I just felt that the interior was too much of a let down and I wanted to make that point loud and clear and it seemed to have worked.
With cars like the Jag XJ worth less than three times the price of the Supersports how the heck did it end up with an interior that is much better than the Supersports interior? When a car costs $273,000, there is absolutely no excuse for a lousy interior. The Supersports deserves an interior that looks at least half as good as the Mulsanne or Brooklands interior. I'll agree with you that the ownership experience of a Phaeton vs. Conti GT would be vastly different but I don't believe that the driving experience is different enough. Sure the Phaeton won't be as fast or have as good of dynamics as the Conti GT but the bottom line is that both cars would leave you cold after driving them. Now, i've never had the chance to drive a Phaeton but I can guarantee you that it won't be as exciting as a Supersports. And if the Supersports failed to excite me than I doubt the Phaeton would even register a blip.
Before I start sounding arrogant I just want to say that I still appreciate the little details in every car that I drive. Here are some from recent memory:
The condensation forming on the Jag XJ's metal air vents.The "squish" heard from the Aston Vanquish' transmission hydraulics on each up shift. The way the Maserati Gran Sport revs by itself on a cold morning when you first start it up. The impossible-to-describe way the Ferrari 599 tach moves in perfect increments with the way the engine sounds. To me, all of these things make cars exciting to drive. They give cars a soul, something that elevates them from simply being a machine.
Speaking of car mags, Car and Driver is probably near the end of all the mags IMO, although R&T isn't much better. Automobile, another mag based in my hometown of Ann Arbor, is probably the best domestic mag. Now, the mag that I enjoy the most by far is EVO, i've got every single issue besides issue 1. CAR is another great Brit mag and they have some interesting articles. Basically, no domestic mag is going to come close to the British mags any time soon.
If you want clear, honest, and well written articles then just read anything by Chris Harris, Jethro Bovingdon, Georg Kacher, Ian Kuah, John Barker, or Richard Meaden.
It sure is fun talking to someone that's as crazy about cars as myself :D.